Wikipedia Notability: Bukti yang Disusun
Cara menyusun bukti notability untuk submission Wikipedia yang lolos review editor. Document stack yang mendukung argumen 'this entity is notable'.
Wikipedia editor evaluate based on Wikipedia:Notability guidelines. Self-assessment saja tidak cukup. Menyusun 'notability packet' adalah pre-work yang menentukan apakah article bertahan atau cepat didelete. Ini protokol yang saya pakai.
Document stack (company)
- 3+ artikel media nasional substantif. Minimum 300 kata, mainstream outlet.
- 2+ artikel editorial (bukan press placement). Independent journalism.
- Industry data yang menyebut sebagai notable player. Market share, rank.
- Government atau regulator recognition. License, certification yang meaningful.
- Institutional mention. University, research, government document.
- Award or recognition. Industry-level.
- Sustained coverage 2+ years. Bukan satu burst moment.
Document stack (person)
- Published books (multiple, with ISBN). Traditional publisher atau self dengan established presence.
- Academic citation (Google Scholar > 10 citations). Peer recognition.
- Sustained media coverage. Feature pieces, interview, quote.
- Institutional roles. Board, committee, significant position.
- Award or honor from notable body. Government, academic, industry.
- Speaking at notable venues. Conference dengan Wikipedia article sendiri.
- Influence documented. Cited in policy, curriculum, public discourse.
Source yang Wikipedia prefer
Strong source
- Kompas, Tempo, KONTAN, Reuters, Bloomberg.
- Peer-reviewed academic journal.
- Government publication.
- Established industry publication.
- Book published by notable publisher.
Weak atau rejected
- Press release distributed.
- Blog personal tanpa editorial.
- Social media post.
- Company's own website.
- Wikipedia itself (circular).
Format notability packet
Notability Assessment: [Entity Name]
1. Significant coverage summary
[Entity] has been covered substantively in [N] editorial articles
across [N] mainstream Indonesian outlets between [year]-[year].
2. Source list (annotated)
[Source 1]:
Outlet: Kompas
Date: 2024-03-15
Title: "PT Witanabe Tunjuk Sebagai..."
URL: https://kompas.id/...
Coverage: 450 words substantive about...
Source type: Editorial (not press release)
[Source 2]: ...
3. Institutional recognition
- KADIN Komite Tetap membership (2025-)
- ISO 9001:2015 certified (2023-)
- LKPP registered vendor Level 2
4. Industry impact
- Market share data [specific]
- Client base [representative]
- Technology contribution [if applicable]
5. Biographical (for Person articles)
- Publications: 6 books (Google Play Books)
- Speaking: 11 engagements since 2021
- Awards: Wall of Talent Kriya 2020
Submission strategy
- Self-assess dulu (skor notability test No. 20)
Minimum 5/7 sebelum submit.
- Prepare notability packet
Comprehensive document dengan source.
- Draft article yang NPOV (Neutral Point of View)
Tidak promotional. Fact-based only.
- Peer review sebelum submit
Minta Wikipedia editor senior (misal via IRC #wikipedia-id) review draft.
- Submit via Articles for Creation
Bukan create direct. AfC review memberikan feedback sebelum public.
- Respond constructive ke feedback
Editor sering request additional source atau rewording.
- Post-approval: maintain
Watch changes. Respond bila vandalism atau disputes.
Submit terlalu early = speedy deletion. Mark sebagai 'company bio spam' oleh editor. Akan lebih susah submit 6 bulan kemudian. Pastikan notability well-documented before submit.
